Interview with Seth Holmes

Hello Seth Holmes! Thank you so much for taking the time to do this interview. We deeply appreciate you taking the time to speak with us today. To begin, could you please share a bit about your background and the journey that led you to your artistic pursuits? In particular, we're curious about when you first recognized your talent. Growing up, I did some drawing, but it was mostly Dragon Ball Z characters or charcoal drawings of my teachers’ kids so I could make some money. However, I never really saw myself as an artist when I was growing up. I first started playing guitar around age 14, and once I found music I pretty much stopped drawing altogether for years. I had a serious band after high school and was hired at a local tattoo shop as summer help, where I worked my way up to piercer and shop manager. When my band broke up I needed a job. Since I already worked in a shop and had been reteaching myself to draw for a couple years, it seemed like I had a good foot in the door to the tattoo industry. I had always been passionate about getting tattooed, and tattoo culture in general. From there I got an apprenticeship in 2012 and have been professionally tattooing since 2013.

Q: Could you describe the initial catalyst that drew you to tattooing, and how your motivation has developed and transformed throughout your career?
A: I had always been fascinated with the “heavily tattooed” look ever since I was a child. I’ve known since I was 9 or 10 years old that that’s how I wanted to look when I became an adult. I was enamored with rock stars, bikers and outlaws to the point that I used to draw on my arms as a child. As a late teen, getting to work in a tattoo shop only fueled that fire even more. I was getting tattooed at the shop on a bi-weekly basis for a while until I had a sleeve, my hand, and neck tattooed. As I progress into my career, I try not to concern myself with “motivation” as it tends to come and go. But I believe it’s more important to stay disciplined in this craft. Where motivation wanes, discipline will aid the progress of your art more effectively. It’s 10,000 hours of hard work that makes you great at something, not 10,000 hours motivation.

Q: Your portfolio showcases a remarkable range of styles, from realism to traditional and neo-traditional designs. Within that diverse spectrum, are there any particular styles that resonate with you most deeply, and if so, why?
A: Thank you so much for the kind words. For me, personally I enjoy and respect every style of tattooing. I don’t just love one style. I love TATTOOING in general. I am constantly trying to find ways to mix styles together, or to take certain aspects of one style and apply it to another. And to be honest, trying to achieve different styles helps to prevent burnout and creative plateaus. If you’re never able to perfect one style, you’ll never stop progressing and your work is less likely to get boring.

Q: Which one do you find as most difficult?
A: I used to say that color realism is the most challenging style to tattoo. However, as I become more diverse in my portfolio and continuously try different techniques, my opinion has changed. Geometric, biomech, and Japanese traditional are the most difficult in my opinion now. Each one of these styles have certain “rules” to abide by, and to me, rules are only meant to be broken AFTER you learn them thoroughly first.

Q: To what extent do you feel that strong drawing skills contribute to the overall quality and artistry of a tattooing, recognizing that tattooing itself is a specialized technique?
A: This might grind the gears of a lot of tattooers out there, but honestly I think there’s a few tattoo styles where you don’t really have to know how to draw. As long as you can copy something efficiently, and have great tattooing technique, realism, American traditional, and geometric tattoos don’t require a ton of pure drawing skill. New school, biomech, illustrative, neo traditional (or neo romantic as some tattooers are calling it now), etc require a lot more ability to draw in my opinion. This is why I believe it’s significantly more important to hone your technical skills as a tattooer. Art itself may be subjective, but tattoos are not. If a tattoo is not applied well technically, it’s still a bad tattoo regardless of the drawing ability of the tattooer. Over the years I’ve seen great artists who can’t tattoo well, and great tattooers who can’t draw.

Q: What was your learning process like? Were you guided by experienced artists, or did you primarily rely on self-teaching?
A: I had a less-than-traditional apprenticeship, but I did have the ability to learn from some amazing artists at the shop where I started. I feel like every tattoo artist has a mix of both learning from others, and self-teaching. Personally, a lot of the technical side of this craft came from getting tattooed and watching others, while a lot of the artistic side came from self-teaching and experimentation. I’m still learning from the artists I work with every day.

Q: Reflecting on that journey, at what point did you feel confident in your abilities?
A: I became confident in my ability to produce great tattoos after about 4-5 years into my career. Much of that time was spent traveling doing guest spots, attending conventions, asking for portfolio critiques from artists I looked up to, and getting tattooed by those artists as well.

Q: How significantly do you believe the widespread exposure to tattoo art through media platforms, like social media and television, has influenced the demand for more personalized and unconventional designs?
A: Social media and television shows have completely changed the industry. I started working in a shop before Instagram was an app, so I remember when you had to wait for the next physical tattoo magazine to come in the mail to read an interview and see amazing tattoos. Since the advent of Instagram, you now see incredible tattoos every minute of every day. And you can message those artists directly to talk about supplies, technique, references, etc. I feel like it’s so much easier to get good at tattooing in such a short period of time now that social media has taken over how we communicate with each other. As for TV shows, I’m all for them. I know a lot of tattooers complain about the clientele acting like they know more about tattooing just because they’ve seen every season of LA Ink or Ink Master, but these shows are great for our industry. They’ve made us all significantly busier and they’ve made tattoos more socially acceptable. Look, TV shows are a double-edged sword, but I believe they’ve been more helpful than not. These shows are a big reason why more people want custom artwork instead of flash off of the wall.

Q: Considering the contemporary expansion of tattoo styles, such as neo-traditional, how do you approach the possibility of combining diverse techniques to create unique, cohesive designs?
A: As I mentioned earlier in this interview, I am always trying to push the boundaries of what I can incorporate into a tattoo style-wise. If, for example, a color realism piece would be more visually appealing if it had a bold black outline, I’m going to add it. I care most about how this tattoo is going to be read from across the street. If you can tell what the design is from 10 feet away, regardless of style, I feel that I’ve done my job well.

Q: That Salvador Dali portrait... Amazing! Tattoo realism demand extraordinary technical skill. What specific artistic challenges within this style do you find most compelling?
A: I truly appreciate that! Thank you so much! With color realism, especially portraits, I think the most challenging part is tattooing the eyes accurately. What’s most compelling for me is trying to get the viewer of the tattoo to know who that portrait is without any hesitation.

Q: Which do you find more creatively stimulating: working with color or black and gray tattooing, and why?
A: They’re both equally stimulating for me. I genuinely enjoy tattooing both color and black & grey designs. That way I never get bored with my work.

Q: For a tattoo artist seeking recognition, is it more beneficial to specialize in a single style or to demonstrate proficiency in a variety of styles?
A: Here’s the thing when it comes to picking a style in tattooing. I completely understand why some people believe in picking a single style and only doing that one thing. I get where they’re coming from. Make your one style PERFECT, right? However, in my opinion that is incredibly boring and will lead to burnout eventually. Maybe I’m wrong? Maybe the artists who only do one specific style never get bored. But I do, so I can’t relate to that way of thinking. I also believe that versatility is a strength when it comes to having a lot of clientele, and keeping yourself busy during the slow seasons or economic recessions. Let’s say 50% of people in your area want black & grey tattoos, but you only do color. Well, you’ve just potentially cut off 50% of your ability to bring in money when it gets slow. To me it always made sense both artistically and financially to be as good at as many styles as you can.

Q: Can you recall a technically demanding tattoo that you found exceptionally rewarding upon completion?
A: Absolutely. I recently completed a large torso tattoo that included mastectomy scar cover ups. Not only was it rewarding artistically, but personally as well. To be given the trust to change someone’s life like that means more than words can describe. I am forever grateful for the clientele I have built over these years.

Q: Your digital work is fantastic. How does your design process work? Do you prepare sketches in advance, or do you prefer to develop the design collaboratively with clients on the day of their appointment?
A: I truly appreciate that. My process is different than most artists. I typically draw for the client’s tattoo early that same morning, before they arrive. I have my assistant get all of the info for their design ahead of time, and I’ll often request consultations with them as well in order to get every detail of what they want. Then when they arrive for their appointment time, my drawing and stencil are already complete. My station is also always set up and ready before they arrive as well. This way, the client never has to wait more than 30 minutes after arriving before the needle is touching skin.

Q: Your portfolio suggests a strong visual style that could translate effectively to mediums beyond tattooing, like book illustration or clothing design. Are there any avenues of creative expansion you're currently exploring or considering?
A: I'm actually working on some clothing for release in the near future. Although I’ve never considered book illustrations, that might be something I’d be interested in if an author ever came to me with an inquiry.

Q: Presenting fresh and healed tattoo photos demonstrates a high level of transparency and professionalism. It's a key factor in setting realistic expectations for clients. What inspired you to incorporate this practice into your portfolio?
A: This stems back from before I tattooed, when I was just a client. I would always see mountains of portfolios from artists with only fresh pictures, and very rarely would there be healed photos in them. So it’s been important to me from the time I started tattooing to document the healing process. I believe that it’s the ultimate transparency for your clientele. If you can’t see any healed photos from an artist, whether the tattoos look amazing or not, that is a huge red flag.

Q: Earning client trust requires both exceptional tattoo skills and unwavering ethical behavior. A good reputation solidifies this trust, guaranteeing clients a quality tattoo. What, in your opinion, is the most effective way to maintain this crucial reputation?
A: To me, a great reputation stems from providing the client with a great experience first and foremost. There are too many good tattooers now to be able to compete with artistic ability alone. Making sure the client is comfortable, respecting their time, good conversation and some hospitality will go a long way for your reputation. I know of countless tattoo artists who do incredible work, but have poor reputations. If you are always late, don’t care about the pain level of your clients and wear headphones while tattooing (essentially ignoring your client), then I can totally understand why someone would stop getting tattooed by you regardless of your skill with a machine. I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it a million times over. I would rather be covered in mediocre tattoos by someone I enjoy being around, than have one “masterpiece” tattoo by someone who was late and had a poor attitude while tattooing me.

Q: Given complete creative license, what would your ideal tattoo design project be?
A: This is a difficult question to answer. Any large scale project where I’m able to combine any style and subject matter into a cohesive sleeve/leg panel/backpiece/torso would be a dream come true.

Q: Collaborative tattooing is becoming increasingly prevalent. Are there any other artists whose work you admire and with whom you'd be interested in exploring a collaborative project?
A: This is interesting to me because I have been doing collaborative tattoos for a very long time. I love the idea of two artists coming together and creating something extremely unique for the client that nobody else can have. I have done collab tattoos with Jake Ross, Ulyss Blair, Jay Joree, Matt Wright, and Manu Cruz. I would love the opportunity to do a collab tattoo with London Reese or Steve Moore. I am always down for collaborations!

Q: What's your take on the local tattoo scene? Are you seeing any exciting developments, like new artists, styles, or events?
A: Pittsburgh has always been a “tattoo city.” We have artists of every style here and the talent pool is insanely deep. I have to shout out the shop and the people I work with. Ross, Dexter, Matt, Ari, Michele. Each one of them are killer artists and I feel like Foundation Tattoo Parlor, where I call “home,” is the best shop in the city. I also have to shout out Somewhere Good Tattoo and Triumphant Arts Tattoo Studio. These shops have amazing tattooers and great people working there as well.

Q: Please write down your studio location and website/social media links. Also let us know if you are available for bookings.
A: Foundation Tattoo Parlor, Pittsburgh PA. And you can find me on Instagram or Threads @sethholmestattoo. If you search “Seth Holmes” on Facebook I’m there as well, just not very active. As for booking, all inquiries go through my amazing assistant Brittany at sethholmestattoos@gmail.com. I typically don’t book myself more than 2 months, so it’s not usually a long wait to get an appointment.

Q: How do you perceive the current trends and evolution of the global tattoo scene, and what aspects do you find particularly promising or concerning?
A: For the most part I think the evolution in tattooing around the world is incredible. It seems like every day I’m finding a new artist from a different country who is producing mind-blowing artwork and solid technical tattooing. The only thing I find concerning is the advent and popularity of “ignorant style” tattooing. Sorry not sorry, but tattooing horrible designs on purpose is not a “style” in my opinion. You’re just guaranteeing that local artists have cover ups to do in the future.

Q: How has your passion for tattooing progressed throughout your career? Do you find your enthusiasm has remained constant, or has it evolved and deepened over time?
A: I had some dark years in my career fueled by alcohol and drugs. I was in a horrible place mentally and almost quit tattooing at one point. Realizing the problem was internal, I quit drinking and hard drugs 5 years ago. Since then, my fire has never burned brighter. I am more passionate about tattooing now than when I first started. With a clean mind, and clean bill of health, I am producing the best work of my entire journey in this trade.

Q: If you could go back and give your younger self advice about pursuing tattooing, what would it be?
A: My advice to my younger self would be that the grass isn’t always greener. For a long time in my early career, I was constantly trying to find the right place to fit in. Not artistically, but personally. Over the years I’ve learned a few important things I wish I knew earlier. Mainly that while drugs and alcohol are fun, they’ll also destroy your ambition, and that it’s true when they say “never meet your idols, they’ll only disappoint you.”